The FAA's regular equipment budget has been squeezed for decades, and the billions it has spent on upgrades have underdelivered. Friday's failure happened on a network it decided to replace in 2023.
Ground stop: 3:54 p.m. to 8:15 p.m. ET (ABC News); lifesaving, law-enforcement and military flights continued. Cancellations: FAA questions and answers, November 15, 2026; 9,082 of them by major airlines. Saturday added more than 6,400, according to FlightAware. Budget: the regular Facilities and Equipment appropriation in 2024 dollars, $4.84 billion in 1991 and $3.19 billion in 2024, my calculation from Eno Center and FAA figures; it leaves out the infrastructure-law and 2025 reconciliation money covered in section 03. Systems: GAO, September 2024.
02 What is known, and what is not
03 FAA funding since 1991
04 Where the money comes from
05 The modernization graveyard
06 How old the equipment really is
07 What DOGE actually did at the FAA
08 The controller shortage
09 Shutdowns and stopgaps
10 Does money explain the failure?
11 How other countries run it
12 What a fix costs, and who pays
13 Timeline
01The Four and a Half Hours
Here is Friday as the FAA, the Transportation Department and the controllers' union have described it so far. Step through it.
From statements and briefings by Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford on November 13-15, 2026, as reported by ABC News, Yahoo News and NBC News, and from the controllers' union. Times are Eastern.
The only comparable event in recent memory was January 11, 2023, when the FAA's system for sending safety notices to pilots, called NOTAM, failed and the agency stopped departures nationwide for about an hour and a half on a weekday morning. The FAA later said contractors had unintentionally deleted files while fixing a database. Then, as now, the failure started with routine work by a contractor on a system the FAA knew was old.
02What Is Known, and What Is Not
Within 48 hours the official explanation changed shape. On Friday night Duffy blamed aging switches and routers that were "overloaded with data." By Saturday he was talking about "routine maintenance" by L3Harris and said officials were still working out "whether we had incompetence" or a faulty router. Here is where things stand.
| Question | What has been said | Status |
|---|---|---|
| What failed | The FTI network, a private telecom network linking control centers, towers and radar sites at more than 4,000 locations. A router at a remote site flooded other routers; one in Amarillo, Texas also did. | Stated by officials |
| Why the router misbehaved | Officials are checking whether it was defective, installed wrong or misconfigured. Both routers are at an L3Harris lab in Florida, and the FBI is involved. | Unknown |
| A cyberattack? | Duffy: "we don't believe this was cyber at all." Bedford: "zero evidence of anything nefarious." | No evidence so far |
| The new AI system? | The FAA had just rolled out SMART, an $875 million AI traffic-management tool. Its maker says it was not the cause, and Bedford said there is "zero evidence of anything AI related." | No evidence so far |
| Has it happened before? | Yes. In 2009 a Harris Corp. technician misconfigured a router during a fiber move, disrupting 129 FAA facilities, according to a Transportation Department inspector general review. | On the record |
| Lack of money? | Duffy and Bedford say the network "will continue to break until we replace it." Democrats say the FAA is sitting on unspent modernization money. Section 10 weighs this. | Disputed |
Sources: FAA, ABC News, Yahoo News. The investigation has not reported yet. This section reflects statements through November 15, 2026.
03FAA Funding Since 1991
The FAA is a roughly $21 billion a year agency, before the one-off money of the last few years. About 60% of that goes to operations: mostly paying the controllers, technicians and safety inspectors who keep the system running. A much smaller account, Facilities and Equipment, pays for the radars, radios, computers, telecom lines and buildings themselves. That split is the heart of the story.
1991-2021 from the Eno Center for Transportation (January 2023); 2024 from the FAA's Airport and Airway Trust Fund fact sheet. Adjusted with the annual average CPI-U; use the DaveManuel.com inflation calculator to check any year.
After inflation, the operations budget grew about 37% between 1991 and 2024. The equipment budget shrank about 34%. Eno's Jeff Davis put the growth rates at 3.5% a year for operations and 1.6% for equipment between 1991 and 2021, in nominal terms, and called it the rule rather than the exception: when appropriators are squeezed, salaries get paid and the radar replacement waits.
Annual accounts only. The 2025 and 2026 ratios leave out the one-off money: $1 billion a year for air traffic facilities from the 2021 infrastructure law (fiscal 2022 to 2026) and $12.52 billion from the July 2025 reconciliation law. 2026 is the enacted appropriation, per Eno.
The last five years broke the pattern, because Congress went around the annual budget. The 2021 infrastructure law added $5 billion for air traffic facilities over five years, and the July 2025 reconciliation law added $12.52 billion for a new air traffic control system, available through fiscal 2029. Counting everything, the FAA had $38.5 billion of budget authority in fiscal 2025, against $25.1 billion the year before.
FAA Airport and Airway Trust Fund fact sheet, 2026 edition. The 2021 supplementals were COVID relief for airports ($10 billion); 2025 is the reconciliation law's $12.52 billion for air traffic control.
04Where the Money Comes From
Unlike most agencies, the FAA is mostly paid for by the people who use it. Taxes on tickets, cargo and fuel go into the Airport and Airway Trust Fund, created in 1970, and the trust fund paid for about 93% to 94% of the FAA's regular budget in fiscal 2024 and 2025. The rest comes from the Treasury's general fund, a share that has ranged from zero in fiscal 2000 to 38% in fiscal 1997, according to the Congressional Research Service.
Airline passengers carry almost all of it. Ticket taxes and segment fees raised $15.9 billion, about 69%, and international arrival and departure taxes another $5.6 billion. Fuel is a rounding error: commercial jet fuel is taxed at 4.3 cents a gallon, and private and general aviation fuel together raised about $460 million. Who pays is a long-running fight between the airlines and business aviation, and it explains why the trust fund grows when people fly and shrinks when they stop.
Here is what your own ticket sends where. Enter the base fare, before taxes and fees, for a one-way trip.
2026 rates: 7.5% domestic ticket tax and $5.30 per domestic flight segment (FAA). Passenger facility charges are capped at $4.50 a boarding and $18 a round trip, and go to the airports. The TSA security fee is $5.60 per one-way trip. Domestic trips only; international trips pay the $23.40 arrival and departure taxes instead of the 7.5%.
The trust fund has its own history of political accidents. Congress let the taxes lapse from January 1 to August 27, 1996, losing an estimated $4 billion, and again from January 1 to February 28, 1997, losing about $1 billion. In 2011 a fight over the FAA's reauthorization shut down parts of the agency from July 23 to August 5, furloughing about 4,000 FAA employees and costing about $400 million in uncollected taxes; many airlines raised fares by the amount of the lapsed tax and kept the money.
05The Modernization Graveyard
If the equipment budget was too small, the obvious question is what happened when the FAA got big money for new equipment. Twice before, the answer was disappointing.
GAO, report RCED-95-175FS (1995). The 1994 figure was the cost to complete AAS and related projects.
The third attempt is under way now. In May 2025 Duffy announced what the department calls the Brand New Air Traffic Control System, and in July 2025 Congress gave it $12.52 billion: $4.75 billion for telecommunications, $3 billion for radars, and the rest for radios, towers and the rest of the plumbing. The first phase now costs about $16 billion, Bedford told Congress in September 2026. A GAO report that month found the FAA had replaced 2,560 of its 5,170 copper lines with fiber as of May 2026, but had no comprehensive lifecycle cost estimate and 11,389 separate project schedules that were not integrated. Bedford disputed both findings.
06How Old the Equipment Really Is
The best single measure comes from the FAA's own 2023 review of 138 air traffic control systems, which GAO published in September 2024.
Of the 105 at-risk systems, 58 were rated as having a critical effect on safety and efficiency. GAO singled out 17 that were both the most critical and the most at risk: 13 had fixes scheduled between 2030 and 2035, and four had no modernization project at all. The details people quote are real: FAA leaders told Congress in 2025 that some systems still ran on floppy disks, the controllers' union said on Saturday that some still do, and on Friday Bedford said maintenance on the network is logged on paper. The network itself, FTI, was designed around copper telecom circuits of the kind phone companies are retiring.
GAO-24-107001, "FAA Actions Are Urgently Needed to Modernize Aging Systems," September 23, 2024.
07What DOGE Actually Did at the FAA
A lot of what circulates about DOGE and the FAA is guesswork, so I have kept to what is documented.
| Claim | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| DOGE fired FAA workers | True, on a small scale. Starting February 14, 2025, as part of the administration's government-wide firing of probationary staff that DOGE drove, the FAA let go employees hired in the past year or so. Duffy said "fewer than 400" across the agency, about 1% of the workforce. The technicians' union, PASS, said 133 of its members were let go, in jobs from program analysts and aeronautical information specialists to maintenance mechanics and telecommunications specialists. |
| DOGE fired air traffic controllers | Not supported. The White House said no controllers or safety-critical staff were fired, and the FAA's list given to PASS included none of the technicians who maintain air traffic control equipment. |
| Musk tried to give the FAA's network to Starlink | Partly. In February 2025 SpaceX engineers visited the FAA, the agency tested four Starlink terminals at non-safety-critical sites, and Musk said Verizon's system was "not working." The Washington Post reported the FAA was close to canceling Verizon's $2.4 billion network contract. The FAA said no decision had been made, and in August 2026 it gave the job to AT&T, not Starlink. |
| DOGE caused Friday's outage | No evidence. The failure was on the L3Harris-run FTI network during contractor work, and none of the officials, the union or the coverage I read has linked it to the 2025 firings. |
The DOGE story at the FAA is mostly about what did not change. The cuts were small, they missed the controllers and equipment technicians, and the network contract that drew Musk's attention went to another phone company. The larger change that happened on DOGE's watch, the $12.52 billion for modernization, came from Congress.
08The Controller Shortage
Staffing is a separate problem from equipment, and Friday was an equipment failure. But the two meet whenever something breaks, because short-staffed facilities have less slack to cope. The shortage goes back to 1981, when President Reagan fired more than 11,000 striking controllers, and the FAA has struggled to keep training pipelines ahead of retirements ever since.
FAA workforce plans as reported by AVweb (May 18, 2026). The 14,633 target was set in 2023 by the FAA and the controllers' union.
In May 2026 the FAA cut its target by about 2,000, to 12,563, saying it could run the system safely with fewer controllers than it thought; the union said it was not involved in the plan. The FAA hired 2,028 trainees in fiscal 2025, the most since 2008, and plans 2,200, 2,300 and 2,400 over the next three years. Newark shows how the problems overlap: its approach control was moved to Philadelphia in July 2024 because of staffing, it lost radar and radio contact for about 90 seconds twice in spring 2025, and on September 21, 2026 a cut fiber line and a failed circuit at the same Philadelphia facility grounded flights at five Northeast airports.
09Shutdowns and Stopgaps
Stop-start budgets are their own kind of cut, because modernization contracts run for years and an agency that does not know its next year's budget signs fewer of them. Eno found appropriators gave the FAA $841 million less for equipment than Congress had authorized over the five years of its last reauthorization, even counting infrastructure-law money. The record of the last 30 years:
| When | What happened |
|---|---|
| 1996 and 1997 | Trust fund taxes lapsed twice, for about ten months in total, losing about $5 billion. |
| July-Aug 2011 | A reauthorization fight partly shut the FAA for two weeks: about 4,000 employees furloughed, airport construction stopped, about $400 million of taxes uncollected. |
| April 2013 | Budget sequestration forced controller furloughs and delays nationwide; within two weeks Congress let the FAA move money to end them. |
| Jan 2019 | In the 35-day shutdown, controllers worked unpaid; the shutdown ended hours after staffing shortages slowed flights into LaGuardia on January 25. |
| Oct-Nov 2025 | The 43-day shutdown left controllers unpaid again; on November 5 the FAA ordered airlines to cut up to 10% of flights at 40 major airports. |
The next deadline is December 11, 2026, when the government's current funding runs out, and appropriators are negotiating now.
10Does Money Explain the Failure?
This is where I have landed, taking each explanation on its own.
| Explanation | Evidence | Link to Friday |
|---|---|---|
| The equipment budget was starved | Down about a third after inflation since 1991 while operations grew; 105 of 138 systems at risk. | Strong, but indirect |
| The FAA wastes the big money it gets | AAS tripled in cost and was broken up; NextGen had delivered about 16% of its expected lifetime benefits by 2024, years behind its early promises; GAO says the new program still lacks a full cost estimate. | Partial |
| A contractor network nobody replaced | FTI dates from a 2002 contract. The FAA picked Verizon to replace it in March 2023, with IP conversion due by 2027, then restructured the job and gave it to AT&T in August 2026. Friday's failure began during routine router work on that old network, which the FAA says was separate from the modernization program; the root cause is still under investigation. | Most direct |
| Not enough money right now | $12.52 billion arrived in July 2025; Duffy says about a third has been spent, and that none of it can pay for a new telecom architecture. Democrats ask why more is needed while money remains unspent. Neither side has separated money appropriated, money committed under contracts, and money actually paid out. | Disputed |
| DOGE cuts | About 400 probationary firings, no controllers or equipment technicians. | No evidence |
| The controller shortage | Real and long-running, but Friday began with a router, not a staffing gap. | Not the cause |
Money explains why the system is old. For 30 years the FAA was given far less for equipment than for people, and Congress's habit of stopgaps and shutdowns made long contracts harder. But money on its own does not explain Friday. The network that failed is one the FAA decided to replace more than three years ago, the replacement was re-awarded only this August, and the failure began during routine work on the old network while the replacement was still years from done. That points to how the FAA buys and manages technology at least as much as how much it is given, which is also what AAS and NextGen teach.
On the unspent money, a dollar can be appropriated by Congress, obligated when the FAA signs a contract, and paid out when the work is done. Big equipment programs pay out slowly by design, so unpaid money is not the same as idle money. Duffy's "about a third" did not say which of those he meant, and the FAA has not published a breakdown, so neither side's claim can be checked yet.
It also cuts both ways politically. The $12.52 billion came in a party-line bill that no Democrat voted for, and Democrats now argue that the money it provided should be enough for now; Republicans who wrote it now say it was only a down payment. Johnson, the outgoing House Speaker, said Congress does not need an investigation "to understand we need further investment." The investigation still matters, because it will say whether Friday was bad luck on an old network or a contractor mistake that more money would not have prevented.
11How Other Countries Run It
The United States is unusual in running air traffic control inside a government agency funded by annual appropriations. Several countries moved it out decades ago.
| Country | Who runs it | How it is paid for |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | Nav Canada, a private not-for-profit company with no shareholders, which bought the system from the government for C$1.5 billion in 1996. | Fees charged to airlines and other users. It borrows on its own credit for new equipment. |
| United Kingdom | NATS, a public-private partnership since 2001: the government keeps a minority stake and a golden share. | Regulated user charges. |
| United States | The FAA, a federal agency. | Mostly aviation excise taxes through the trust fund, spent only when Congress appropriates. |
Moving the US system out of the FAA was proposed in 2017, in Congress's AIRR Act, and dropped after opposition from business aviation and rural lawmakers. None of the 2026 proposals go that far. They argue only about how much to spend and through whom.
12What a Fix Costs, and Who Pays
The price tag has moved a lot in 16 months, and the numbers are not all measuring the same thing.
Provided: P.L. 119-21. Requests: AeroTime (October 2025), AOPA (September 24, 2026) and CNN (November 15, 2026). Separately, Bedford said on November 14 that about $10.1 billion more is needed to finish the current modernization, and in September the FAA put the figure at about $20 billion to finish by the end of 2028; the gaps between these numbers reflect different scopes.
Who pays depends on the vehicle. Money from a reconciliation bill or a general appropriation comes from the Treasury, which means more borrowing at today's deficits; DaveManuel.com's national debt clock and Balance the Budget page put that in context. Money from the trust fund comes from passengers, and for scale, all the ticket taxes and segment fees together raised $15.9 billion in the latest year, so a $30 billion request is roughly two years of every domestic ticket tax. Democrats such as Sen. Brian Schatz have proposed taking some of it from the $75 billion the 2025 law gave immigration enforcement. With Democrats taking the House in January, the answer will come out of a divided Congress, which I wrote about in Is Gridlock Good for the Stock Market?.
13Timeline
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1970 | Congress creates the Airport and Airway Trust Fund, paid for by aviation taxes. |
| 1981 | Reagan fires more than 11,000 striking controllers. |
| 1983 | The Advanced Automation System is launched at an estimated $2.5 billion. |
| 1994 | AAS is broken up after its estimate reaches $7.6 billion. |
| 1996-1997 | Aviation taxes lapse twice, costing about $5 billion. |
| 1999 | The ticket tax reaches 7.5%, where it still is. |
| 2002 | Harris Corp. wins the FTI telecom network contract. |
| 2003 | NextGen begins. |
| 2009 | A misconfigured router during a fiber move disrupts 129 FAA facilities. |
| 2011 | A two-week partial FAA shutdown; taxes go uncollected. |
| 2013 | Sequestration furloughs controllers. |
| 2019 | The 35-day shutdown ends after LaGuardia delays. |
| 2021 | The infrastructure law adds $5 billion for air traffic facilities over five years. |
| Jan 2023 | The NOTAM failure stops departures nationwide. |
| Mar 2023 | The FAA picks Verizon to replace FTI, with IP conversion due by 2027. |
| Sept 2024 | GAO reports 105 of 138 systems at risk. |
| Feb 2025 | Probationary FAA employees are fired; FAA tests Starlink terminals. |
| Apr-May 2025 | Newark approach control loses radar and radio contact twice. |
| Jul 2025 | Congress provides $12.52 billion for a new air traffic control system. |
| Sept 2025 | The inspector general finds NextGen had delivered about 16% of its expected benefits. |
| Nov 2025 | The FAA orders flight cuts at 40 airports during the 43-day shutdown. |
| May 2026 | The FAA lowers its controller target to 12,563. |
| Aug 2026 | AT&T replaces Verizon as lead on the new network. |
| Sept 2026 | Duffy asks for $30 billion more; a cut cable and failed circuit ground Northeast flights. |
| Nov 13, 2026 | A router failure on FTI triggers the nationwide ground stop. |
Sources
- Outage: FAA, nationwide ground stop questions and answers (Nov 15, 2026); FAA statement (Nov 13, 2026); ABC News, Duffy says ATC routers' ability to broadcast data turned off and ground stop lifted after more than 4 hours; Yahoo News live coverage (Nov 14, 2026); NBC News; CNN (Nov 15, 2026).
- Budget: Eno Center for Transportation, "Air Traffic Control Snafu Illustrates How Operating Programs Always Squeeze Capital Programs" (Jan 20, 2023) and its fiscal 2026 appropriations review; FAA Airport and Airway Trust Fund fact sheet (2026); Congressional Research Service, R48585 and R44749.
- Equipment and modernization: GAO-24-107001 (Sept 2024); GAO-26-107992 (Sept 2026, as reported by AOPA); GAO RCED-95-175FS (1995); DOT Office of Inspector General NextGen capstone memo (Sept 29, 2025); Aviation Week on the AT&T award.
- DOGE: The Air Current (Feb 18, 2025); The Register (Feb 27, 2025); The Washington Post (Feb 26, 2025).
- Controllers and shutdowns: AVweb (May 18, 2026); AeroCorner on the September 21, 2026 Northeast outage; contemporary coverage of the 2011, 2013, 2019 and 2025 shutdowns.
- Other countries: ICAO case study on Nav Canada.
