Dave Manuel Logo
Tuesday, March 31, 2015
Click Here to Subscribe to My Free Newsletter

DaveManuel.com BLOG POSTS

2009-11-28 09:25:00 - By

Neil Barofsky Releases Report Critical of Geithner and NY Fed

-- Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner -- It has not been a good couple of weeks for Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner.

A report was recently released by special inspector general Neil Barofsky, who was charged with the task of reviewing the payments that were made with taxpayer dollars to counterparties of AIG at the height of the financial meltdown in 2008.

Were the payments nothing more than stealth bailouts for some of Wall Street's largest firms?

Did Geithner wilt under the pressure and back down to the likes of Goldman Sachs?

Should Geithner and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York have forced concessions from the counterparties to AIG instead of paying them out at 100 cents on the dollar and making them completely whole?

Geithner, who was head of the New York Fed at the time. agreed to pay the counterparties to AIG 100 cents on the dollar to "tear up their contracts". At the time, AIG was falling apart at the seams in the face of an epic meltdown of the financial system, and was forced to rely on an $85 billion dollar loan from the Fed to stave off bankruptcy.

Barofsky surmises that the fact that the government didn't let AIG slip into bankruptcy (as they did with Lehman Brothers), instead choosing to provide them with the massive $85 billion dollar loan, eroded any bargaining power that they may have had with the counterparties to AIG.

Fearful of another credit downgrade at AIG, and unwilling to force the company into bankruptcy, Geithner and the NY Fed reportedly decided that they would make all of AIG's counterparties whole, paying out 100 cents on the dollar. These banks (which included the likes of Goldman Sachs) were not willing to accept even a 2% haircut.

Following the release of this report, many have criticized Geithner for not taking a harder line with the banks and forcing concessions.

Many are of the opinion that Geithner's actions were influenced by the likes of Henry Paulson and William Dudley, who were both former employees of Goldman Sachs. At the time of the crisis, Geithner and then-Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson were working in lockstep to try and resolve the mess that had threatened to bring down the global economy. Paulson was the former Chairman and CEO of Goldman Sachs, holding those positions until he resigned in 2006 (to take the position of Treasury Secretary under George W. Bush).

Goldman Sachs, which could have been obliterated if AIG had been allowed to fail, received billions of dollars in taxpayer money, funneled through AIG, after Geithner and the NY Fed agreed to pay them out in full.

Since that point in history, Goldman Sachs has regained its strength and is poised to pay out tens of billions of dollars in bonuses in 2009, just one short year after nearly ceasing to exist, if not for the actions of the NY Fed and Tim Geithner.

Was the NY Fed really not in a position to demand concessions due to the fact that AIG was being propped up by the government?

Did these banks call the NY Fed's (and Geithner's) bluff, forcing the government to bank down at a time when the global financial system was in very real danger of collapsing?

Or did Paulson look out for the best interest of his old buddies at Goldman Sachs and make them whole, using Timothy Geithner as his pawn?

Conspiracy theorists are having a field day with this report, pointing out that this is clear evidence that the government is beholden to Goldman Sachs and not the citizens of the country.

Those who supported the 100% payouts argue that the government was forced into this position due to the fact that they didn't let AIG fail. and they they had no grounds to impose reduced payouts due to the fact that AIG hadn't declared bankruptcy. They also argue that a hardline on the payouts may have resulted in some of the firms sustaining fatal blows that they wouldn't have recovered from.

Was Geithner simply "weak" and unable to stand up to the consortium of banks who were standing firm in their goal of being paid out in full? Did the NY Fed and Geithner really have zero recourse, given that AIG was being propped up by the government?

Or was somebody in Geithner's ear?

Source: Washington Post - Fed Criticized For Not Negotiating Harder with AIG Creditors

Photo: U.S. Treasury

Filed under: General Market News

COMMENTS - What Say You?

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply (No Registration Required)


Your Comment:

Related Articles
Warren Buffet Photo - Heinz and Kraft company logos
Posted on: 2015-03-30 09:12:00
Deutsche Bank: What If Gordon Gekko Had Bought Heinz/Kraft and Not Warren Buffett?
Janet Yellen - Photo taken on January 2015 - Federal Reserve - Press Conference
Posted on: 2015-03-28 04:15:00
Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen: Interest Rates Likely To Start Rising Later in 2015
Kraft and Heinz merger - Illustration - Logos combine
Posted on: 2015-03-25 23:42:00
Heinz and Kraft Merge; Deal Crafted By Warren Buffett and 3G Capital
Senator Ted Cruz - Official Photo - Year 2015
Posted on: 2015-03-23 01:19:00
Cruz Goes First
Tesla Company Logo - T - Version
Posted on: 2015-03-21 09:03:00
Elon Musk: Tesla's Model S Sedans Will Have Autonomous Technology By Summer


Twitter $$


Debt Ceiling Changes (1940-Present)

United States Debt Clock

Where Did The DJIA/NASDAQ/S&P 500 Trade On..

Historical GDP Numbers for the United States

Historical Spending Increases

US Government Spending Breakdown 1962-2015

History of Deficits and Surpluses in the U.S.

History of Debt In The United States

Largest Foreign Holders of US Debt

Historical Gold Prices

Inflation Calculator

What Did It Cost?

Hedge Fund Filings

Historical Unemployment Rates in the United States

Historical State Unemployment Rates

Canada Debt Clock

A History of Bank Failures in the United States

Dow Jones Historical Data

Nasdaq Historical Data

S&P 500 Historical Data

Median Household Income History

House of Representatives History

Compound Interest Calculator

List of Failed US Banks 2015

Historical Unemployment Rates in Canada

UK Debt Clock

Intragovernmental Holdings

Historical Fed Funds Rate

Historical Bitcoin Prices

Financial Twitter Alerts


Institutional Funds Flock To Alibaba

Las Vegas: Democrats Currently The Favorites To Win in 2016

Los Angeles Clippers Likely To Fetch $1 Billion+ in Sale

Mark Cuban Not Sweating His Lack of Involvement in Box IPO

Vince McMahon a Billionaire Once Again

Parsing Obama's 2014 State of the Union Address

NHL Franchise Values Continue To Soar

Twitter To Trade Under TWTR Symbol

Shares of Tesla Drop on Downgrade, Car Fire

More Problems Arise For JC Penney


Etoro Rezension

Os Dois Principais Corretores de Forex no Brasil

Meus Corretores Forex Brasileiros Favoritos


Ted Cruz Net Worth

Marco Rubio Net Worth

Hillary Clinton Net Worth

John Boehner Net Worth

Paul Ryan Net Worth

Rick Santorum Net Worth

Newt Gingrich Net Worth

Mitt Romney Net Worth

Ron Paul Net Worth

Joe Biden Net Worth


Floyd Mayweather, Jr. Net Worth

Russell Wilson Net Worth

Jeb Bush Net Worth

Andrew Luck Net Worth

Lionel Messi Net Worth

Rand Paul Net Worth

Dr. Dre Net Worth

Wayne Rooney Net Worth

Johnny Manziel Net Worth

Stephanie McMahon Net Worth

Satya Nadella Net Worth

Paul Allen Net Worth

Adam Silver Net Worth

Peyton Manning Net Worth





Ballot Box

Market Timer


Cold Storage

Asset Allocation

Surge Pricing

Vault Cash


The Top Three Online Stock Brokers In Canada

The Top Two Forex Brokers in Canada

DraftKings Promo Code - Earn a Bonus of up to $600

FanDuel Promo Code

Hostgator Coupon Code

Daily Fantasy MMA

Daily Fantasy NBA

Daily Fantasy NFL

Daily Fantasy Sports Bonuses


Blog Posts

Company Reviews


General Knowledge

General Market News

Health + Fitness

Hedge Fund News

Internet Companies

Making Money Online


Online Forex Trading

Real Estate News

Stock Market Education

Stock Market Scandals

The Economic Meltdown

Trader Profiles

DaveManuel.com - Copyright 2015, All Rights Reserved | Advertise | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer