Canadian Floor Crossers
The history of MPs who switched parties mid-term and the political drama that followed.
Latest: April 27, 2026: NDP MP Alexandre Boulerice (Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie) leaves caucus to sit as an Independent before resigning his seat on August 25, 2026 to run provincially. As of November 7, 2026 the House of Commons lists 173 Liberal seats - past the 172-seat majority line.
01Crossing the Floor: A Canadian Political Tradition
Floor crossing is one of Canada's most dramatic political traditions. When an MP walks across the House of Commons to join a different party, it represents both political calculation and personal conviction, often triggering controversy about democratic representation and voter trust.
Since Confederation, well over 100 federal MPs have changed party affiliation mid-term, according to Wikipedia's list of Canadian politicians who have crossed the floor (compiled from Library of Parliament records, checked October 2026). This page profiles 37 documented crossings from 1917 to 2026 - counting a sitting MP who joins another party or caucus, or who leaves (or is expelled from) their caucus to sit as an Independent - and every count, chart and percentage below is computed from those 37. The crossers have had varying degrees of success. Some, like David Emerson (Liberal to Conservative, 2006), sparked national outrage. Others, like Scott Brison (Progressive Conservative to Liberal, 2003), built successful long-term careers in their new party. And in the span of just five months - November 2025 through April 2026 - five opposition MPs joined the Liberals, leaving Prime Minister Mark Carney one seat short of a majority - which the Liberals then secured by winning all three April 13, 2026 byelections.
The five outcome counts add up to the 37 crossings in the record table. Two success rates follow from them: 17 wins among the 25 crossers who actually stood in their next election (68%), and 17 wins among all 32 resolved cases, which also count the 6 who retired or resigned and the 1 who lost a nomination as non-wins (53%). The 5 recent crossers who have not yet faced voters are left out of both.
I didn't leave the Conservative Party, the Conservative Party left me.- Common refrain among floor crossers
02Net Party Gains and Losses from Floor Crossing
Net gains and losses by party across the 37 crossings in this page's record table (section 07). The Independent benches gain the most, largely through caucus expulsions; the Conservatives lose the most, with four of their ten departures coming in the 2025-26 Carney-era wave.
03Complete Party Movement Analysis
A breakdown of each party's gains and losses across the 37 crossings in the record table. Each crossing is counted once, from the party the MP left to the party or bench where the crossing ended (an MP who sat as an Independent on the way to a new party is counted at the new party). The Liberals have both gained (15) and lost (13) the most MPs, for a net of +2.
| Party | MPs Gained | MPs Lost | Net Movement | Peak Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal Party | 15 | 13 | +2 | 2025-26 Carney era (five arrivals) |
| Conservative Party (2003-) | 3 | 10 | -7 | 2025-26 Carney-era losses |
| Progressive Conservative | 1 | 5 | -4 | 1990 GST and Meech Lake departures |
| New Democratic Party | 0 | 4 | -4 | Argue (1962) to Idlout and Boulerice (2026) |
| Reform/Alliance | 0 | 2 | -2 | 2001-04 Alliance split and merger |
| Bloc Quebecois | 2 | 0 | +2 | 1990 founding (Bouchard, Lapierre) |
| Independent | 9 | 0 | +9 | Expulsions and walkouts, 1990-2026 |
| Other Parties | 7 | 3 | +4 | 1917-19 Unionist era; Greens, People's Party |
Carney-era effect: The five crossings to Carney's Liberals since November 2025 - four Conservatives (Chris d'Entremont Nov 4, Michael Ma Dec 11, Matt Jeneroux Feb 18, Marilyn Gladu Apr 8) and one New Democrat (Lori Idlout Mar 11) - account for a third of the Liberal arrivals and four of the ten Conservative departures in the record table. On April 27, 2026 NDP MP Alexandre Boulerice also left caucus to sit as an Independent, the NDP's fourth departure in the table. An Angus Reid poll conducted after the crossings found only 26% of Canadians believe floor crossers should be allowed to finish their term with their new party - while 78% of recent Conservative voters now say floor crossing should be banned outright, a dramatic reversal from 2018 when a majority of CPC voters supported the practice.
04Electoral Consequences: Do Floor Crossers Win or Lose?
How the 37 crossers in the record table fared at their next general election. The table leans toward high-profile cases, so these shares describe notable crossings rather than every MP who has ever switched.
05Why MPs Cross the Floor
The motivations behind Canada's most dramatic political decisions, from policy disagreements to personal ambition. Each of the 37 crossings in the record table is assigned one primary reason; the grouping is this page's own classification, not an official one.
Number of crossings by primary reason (this page's classification of the 37 crossings in section 07)
06Timeline: The Most Dramatic Floor Crossings
| 1917 | Liberal Unionists |
| 1990 | Lucien Bouchard |
| 1990 | David Kilgour |
| 2003 | Scott Brison |
| 2005 | Belinda Stronach |
| 2006 | David Emerson |
| 2019 | Jody Wilson-Raybould |
| 2019 | Jane Philpott |
| Nov 4, 2025 | Chris d'Entremont |
| Dec 11, 2025 | Michael Ma |
| Feb 18, 2026 | Matt Jeneroux |
| Mar 11, 2026 | Lori Idlout |
| Apr 8, 2026 | Marilyn Gladu |
| Apr 27, 2026 | Alexandre Boulerice |
07Historical Record: Notable Canadian Floor Crossers
37 documented floor crossings by sitting federal MPs, 1917-2026, with electoral outcomes and career impacts. Every statistic on this page is computed from this table. Rows highlighted in gold are the five recent crossings to the Carney Liberals (2025-26).
| MP Name | Year | From Party | To Party | Primary Reason | Next Election Result | Long-term Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hugh Guthrie | 1917 | Liberal | Unionist | Conscription support | Won | Solicitor General; later interim Conservative leader |
| Frank Carvell | 1917 | Liberal | Unionist | War effort | Won | Minister of Public Works, 1917-1919 |
| Thomas Crerar | 1919 | Unionist | Progressive | Tariff policy / farmers' movement | Won | Progressive Party leader; later Liberal cabinet minister |
| Hazen Argue | 1962 | NDP | Liberal | Lost 1961 NDP leadership | Won | Defeated 1963; later a Liberal senator |
| Real Caouette | 1963 | Social Credit | Ralliement creditiste | Leadership split with Robert Thompson | Won | Led the Ralliement creditiste |
| Paul Hellyer | 1971-72 | Liberal | Progressive Conservative (via Independent Liberal) | Policy disagreements with Trudeau government | Won | Won Trinity as a PC in 1972; defeated 1974 |
| Jack Horner | 1977 | Progressive Conservative | Liberal | Rift with PC leadership / cabinet post | Lost | Political career ended |
| Lucien Bouchard | 1990 | Progressive Conservative | Bloc Quebecois (via Independent) | Meech Lake failure | Won | BQ leader, Quebec Premier |
| David Kilgour | 1990 | Progressive Conservative | Liberal (via Independent) | Expelled over GST opposition | Won | Liberal MP to 2005; then sat as Independent |
| Alex Kindy | 1990 | Progressive Conservative | Independent | Expelled over GST opposition | Lost | Placed fourth as an Independent in 1993 |
| Jean Lapierre | 1990 | Liberal | Bloc Quebecois (via Independent) | Meech Lake failure / Chretien leadership win | Retired | Broadcaster; returned as a Liberal minister in 2004 |
| John Nunziata | 1996 | Liberal | Independent | Expelled after voting against budget (GST promise) | Won | One term as Independent |
| Chuck Strahl | 2001 | Canadian Alliance | Democratic Representative Caucus | Revolt against leader Stockwell Day | Won | Rejoined Alliance 2002; later Conservative cabinet minister |
| Scott Brison | 2003 | Progressive Conservative | Liberal | Conservative merger concerns | Won | 15 years as a Liberal MP, two stints in cabinet |
| Keith Martin | 2004 | Canadian Alliance | Liberal (via Independent) | Declined to join merged Conservative Party | Won | Elected three times as a Liberal |
| Belinda Stronach | 2005 | Conservative | Liberal | Cabinet post / leadership ambitions | Won | Re-elected as a Liberal in 2006; left politics in 2008 |
| Pat O'Brien | 2005 | Liberal | Independent | Opposed same-sex marriage bill | Retired | Did not run in 2006 |
| David Emerson | 2006 | Liberal | Conservative | Cabinet appointment | Retired | Avoided voter judgment |
| Garth Turner | 2006-07 | Conservative | Liberal (via Independent) | Expelled from caucus | Lost | Joined Liberals Feb 2007; defeated in Halton 2008 |
| Wajid Khan | 2007 | Liberal | Conservative | Foreign policy alignment | Lost | Career ended |
| Bill Casey | 2007 | Conservative | Independent | Expelled after budget vote (Atlantic Accord) | Won | Re-elected as Independent 2008; Liberal MP from 2015 |
| Blair Wilson | 2007-08 | Liberal | Green (via Independent) | Left caucus amid campaign-finance allegations | Lost | First Green MP in the House of Commons |
| Lise St-Denis | 2012 | NDP | Liberal | NDP direction after Layton | Retired | Did not run in 2015 |
| Eve Adams | 2015 | Conservative | Liberal | Nomination disputes | Lost nomination | Career ended |
| Leona Alleslev | 2018 | Liberal | Conservative | Economic and foreign-policy disagreements | Won | Re-elected 2019 as a Conservative; defeated 2021 |
| Maxime Bernier | 2018 | Conservative | People's Party | Split with party leadership | Lost | Founded and led the People's Party |
| Raj Grewal | 2018 | Liberal | Independent | Personal financial issues | Retired | Legal troubles |
| Jody Wilson-Raybould | 2019 | Liberal | Independent | Expelled over SNC-Lavalin affair | Won | Successful independent reelection |
| Jane Philpott | 2019 | Liberal | Independent | Expelled over SNC-Lavalin affair | Lost | Career ended |
| Derek Sloan | 2021 | Conservative | Independent | Expelled from caucus | Lost | Fifth as an Independent in Banff-Airdrie, 2021 |
| Jenica Atwin | 2021 | Green | Liberal | Green Party internal turmoil | Won | Re-elected in Fredericton as a Liberal, 2021 |
| Chris d'Entremont | Nov 4, 2025 | Conservative | Liberal | National unity / Carney government | TBD | Sits with Carney Liberals; courted over months by Liberal MP Kody Blois |
| Michael Ma | Dec 11, 2025 | Conservative | Liberal | National unity / Carney government | TBD | Sits with Carney Liberals |
| Matt Jeneroux | Feb 18, 2026 | Conservative | Liberal | "National unity crisis" | TBD | Sits with Carney Liberals; heavily criticized by Poilievre |
| Lori Idlout | Mar 11, 2026 | NDP | Liberal | Sovereignty threats / northern wellbeing | TBD | Brings Liberals to 170 seats; first NDP-Liberal crossing of this era; leaves NDP with 6 MPs |
| Marilyn Gladu | Apr 8, 2026 | Conservative | Liberal | National unity / tariff crisis | TBD | Brings Liberals to 171 seats; 4-term MP, first elected 2015; previously said floor crossers should face byelections |
| Alexandre Boulerice | Apr 27, 2026 | NDP | Independent | Provincial run (Quebec solidaire) | Resigned seat | Left the Commons August 25, 2026 |
Success Rate Analysis: Of the 37 crossings in the table, 17 crossers won their next election, 8 were defeated, 6 retired or resigned before facing voters, 1 (Eve Adams) lost her new party's nomination, and 5 - the Carney-era crossers to the Liberals (d'Entremont, Ma, Jeneroux, Idlout, Gladu) - have yet to face voters in their new party; Boulerice resigned his seat instead. That is 17 wins among the 25 crossers who stood in their next election (68%), or 17 among all 32 resolved cases (53%). Several of the winners - Bouchard, Caouette, Nunziata, Casey and Wilson-Raybould - won for a new party or as Independents rather than for an established rival.
You can't represent the people of Vancouver Kingsway as a Conservative. They didn't elect a Conservative.- Criticism of David Emerson's 2006 floor crossing
08The 2025-26 Carney Wave: Five Crossings in Five Months
The concentrated wave of floor crossings to the Carney Liberals is without modern precedent. Five opposition MPs joining a single government caucus in a five-month span has reshuffled the balance of power in real time - and left Carney one seat short of a majority he was denied at the ballot box, which the April 13, 2026 byelection wins then delivered.
Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre has characterized the crossings as "dirty backroom deals" to seize a majority the Liberals were denied at the ballot box. Poilievre said of Gladu's crossing: "Mark Carney is seizing a costly Liberal majority that voters denied him, and doing so through backroom deals." The Liberals counter that MPs are following their conscience at a critical moment for Canadian sovereignty and economic policy under the shadow of US tariffs. An Angus Reid poll found only 26% of Canadians believe floor crossers should be allowed to finish their term with their new party, while 41% say they should face a byelection. Notably, 78% of recent Conservative voters now say floor crossing should be banned - a dramatic reversal from 2018, when a majority of CPC voters supported the practice.
The Gladu crossing drew particular attention for the sheer gap between her past positions and Liberal values. She had been a vocal opponent of vaccine mandates during COVID-19, once promoted hydroxychloroquine as a treatment when it was unproven, and had publicly stated that floor crossers should step down and run in byelections. AI Minister Evan Solomon, who helped bring Gladu across, told reporters: "This is a pragmatic moment." Carney insisted she would "vote with the government" on social issues.
The three byelections held April 13, 2026 - in University-Rosedale (Toronto), Scarborough Southwest (Toronto), and Terrebonne (Quebec) - were all won by the Liberals (Danielle Martin, Doly Begum and Tatiana Auguste), which combined with Gladu's crossing took the party past the 172-seat majority line. Terrebonne was the closest: the Bloc Quebecois had challenged a one-vote Liberal win from the 2025 federal election all the way to the Supreme Court, and Auguste held the seat by a few hundred votes. The count kept moving after that: Liberal MPs Jonathan Wilkinson (June 2026, named ambassador to the European Union), Nate Erskine-Smith (July 2026), Shaun Chen (August 15) and Steven Guilbeault (August 28) resigned their seats, leaving the party at 170, and the Liberals then won all three August 31, 2026 byelections (Beaches-East York, North Vancouver-Capilano and Chicoutimi-Le Fjord, the last previously held by a Conservative) to reach 173. Update: As of November 7, 2026 the House of Commons party standings list 173 Liberal, 137 Conservative, 21 Bloc Quebecois, 5 NDP and 1 Green MP, with 6 vacant seats - the Liberals are past the 172-seat majority line.
09The Most Successful Floor Crossers in Canadian History
Some floor crossers have not only survived but thrived in their new political homes.
| Scott Brison | PC to Liberal (2003), 15 years as a Liberal MP with two stints in cabinet |
| Keith Martin | Alliance to Liberal (2004), elected three times as a Liberal |
| Lucien Bouchard | PC to BQ (1990), became Quebec Premier |
| Bill Casey | Conservative to Independent (2007), re-elected in 2008 with about 69% of the vote |
Success Factors: The most successful floor crossers in the record table tend to share common characteristics: strong constituency connections, clear policy reasons for switching, and often a move to a party that is rising in popularity. Conversely, crossings seen as trading a seat for personal gain draw the fiercest backlash, as David Emerson found in 2006.
10When and Where Floor Crossing Happens
Geographic Patterns: Ontario MPs account for the most crossings in the record table (14), followed by Quebec (6) and British Columbia (5). Quebec has also produced the largest group defections in the wider historical record, from the 1963 Ralliement creditiste split to the 2018 Bloc Quebecois walkout, and the 1990 and 2000 departures marked the decline of the Progressive Conservatives. The current Carney-era crossings are notable for their geographic diversity - Nova Scotia (d'Entremont), Toronto (Ma), Edmonton (Jeneroux), Nunavut (Idlout), and southern Ontario (Gladu, Sarnia) - suggesting national, not regional, motivations.
11The Verdict: Political Courage or Betrayal?
Canadian floor crossing represents the tension between party loyalty and personal conscience in parliamentary democracy. While some crossings reflect genuine policy disagreements or evolving political convictions, others appear motivated by ambition or opportunism - and voters tend to know the difference.
The electoral record is mixed. In this page's record table, 17 of the 32 crossers with a result won their next election, 8 lost, and 7 retired, resigned or lost a nomination before facing voters - a 68% win rate among the 25 who actually ran, and 53% across all 32 resolved cases. The Angus Reid Institute's polling after the current wave found that only 26% of Canadians believe a crossing MP should be allowed to stay in their seat. Most want a byelection, an independent period, or the seat vacated entirely.
The current wave of crossings to the Carney Liberals - five in five months - is unprecedented in its concentration and its political consequence. Marilyn Gladu's April 8 crossing put the Liberals at 171 seats, and the April 13 byelection sweep then delivered the majority the party was denied at the polls in 2025. Whether that constitutes democratic pragmatism or democratic manipulation is a debate Canadians will be having for years. What isn't debatable is that d'Entremont, Ma, Jeneroux, Idlout, and Gladu have each staked their careers on the move. The voters, as always, will have the final word.
12Sources and Methodology
The 37-row record table was checked in October 2026 against Library of Parliament (ParlInfo) member records and Wikipedia's List of Canadian politicians who have crossed the floor; a crossing is counted when a sitting federal MP joins another party or caucus, or leaves or is expelled from their caucus to sit as an Independent. Resignations to run for another office without a change of affiliation, and party renamings or mergers, are not counted. All counts, charts and percentages on this page are computed from the record table, and the reasons breakdown is this page's own classification. Data on the 2025-26 Carney-era crossings sourced from CBC News, CTV News, CP24, Globe and Mail, Radio-Canada, and Global News (April 2026). Angus Reid Institute floor crossing poll (March 2026). Electoral outcomes tracked through official election results. Data covers federal MPs only; the record table runs from 1917 through November 7, 2026. Seat counts from the House of Commons party standings, checked November 7, 2026.
Corrections and Updates
| Date | What changed |
|---|---|
| October 25, 2026 | Added the win rate among crossers who actually ran (68%, 17 of 25) alongside 53% of all 32 resolved cases, and the missing fifth outcome (1 lost nomination) so the outcome tiles total 37. |
| October 24, 2026 | Corrected Scott Brison's Liberal tenure to 15 years and Belinda Stronach's 2005 role (leadership runner-up, not deputy leader). |
| October 24, 2026 | Rebuilt the record table on 37 verified crossings (removed non-crossings, corrected dates and outcomes, added Argue, Hellyer, Bernier and Atwin) and recomputed every count, tile and chart from it; dated Boulerice's move to April 27, 2026. |
| October 24, 2026 | Corrected the 2026 seat-count explanation: Guilbeault resigned August 28, and the Wilkinson and Erskine-Smith resignations are now included. |
| October 24, 2026 | Explained how the Liberal seat count moved from 174 after the April byelections to 173 (August resignations and byelections). |
| October 24, 2026 | Updated for the Liberals' April 13, 2026 byelection sweep, corrected the meta count and re-election rate, year count, 1917 Unionist entries and the scope of the record table. |
Every correction to a published figure on this site is logged on Sources and Methods.
Cite This Page
This page is free to cite and link. Please include the date you accessed it.
| Format | Citation | Copy |
|---|---|---|
| Plain | Dave Manuel, “Canadian Floor Crossers: Complete History of Party Switchers,” DaveManuel.com, updated November 7, 2026, https://www.davemanuel.com/canadian-floor-crossers-complete-history-party-switchers.php (accessed November 17, 2026). | Copy |
| APA | Manuel, D. (2026). Canadian Floor Crossers: Complete History of Party Switchers. DaveManuel.com. Retrieved November 17, 2026, from https://www.davemanuel.com/canadian-floor-crossers-complete-history-party-switchers.php | Copy |
| Chicago | Manuel, Dave. “Canadian Floor Crossers: Complete History of Party Switchers.” DaveManuel.com. Accessed November 17, 2026. https://www.davemanuel.com/canadian-floor-crossers-complete-history-party-switchers.php. | Copy |
| Wikipedia | {{cite web |url=https://www.davemanuel.com/canadian-floor-crossers-complete-history-party-switchers.php |title=Canadian Floor Crossers: Complete History of Party Switchers |last=Manuel |first=Dave |website=DaveManuel.com |access-date=2026-11-17}} | Copy |
| Link (HTML) | <a href="https://www.davemanuel.com/canadian-floor-crossers-complete-history-party-switchers.php">Canadian Floor Crossers: Complete History of Party Switchers (DaveManuel.com)</a> | Copy |
Page last updated November 7, 2026. How we build our data pages.
